Symbolism of Music in the Shadows
Willa Cather’s Pulitzer prize-winning novel One of Ours is based on the life of her cousin Grosvenor Phillips Cather, who perished in 1918 at the Battle of Cantigny, France, during World War I. One of Ours is divided into five books, with music conspicuously absent from the first three, according to Richard Giannone, author of Music in Willa Cather’s Fiction. Giannone maintains that the dearth of music symbolizes the lack of fulfillment in the life of Claude Wheeler, the fictional version of Cather’s cousin. Claude’s young adulthood is devoid of satisfaction in education, work, place, spirituality, and family and marital relationships.
In developing a playlist for this portion of the book, minor liberties had to be taken. For example, in Book I, Chapter X, Madame Schroeder-Schatz sings for Claude and the Ehrlich family, although Cather makes no mention of a specific musical number. Since it is known that the prototype for Madame Schroeder Schatz was the enigmatic opera singer Ernestine Schumann-Heink, a recording of Schumann-Heink singing “Wiegenlied” from the novel's time period was chosen. Likewise, the beginning of Chapter IV, Book Two, depicts Claude’s friend “whistling an old German song” without naming the tune. Thus, out of the choices available on the music stream, the folk song “Alpenglühn” seemed most fitting.
Novel's Progression Brings Music to Foreground
Music emerges from the shadows in Book IV, “The Voyage of the Anchises,” as Claude embarks on military service that takes him across the Atlantic Ocean to France. This segment is both jubilant, as Claude breaks from his unhappy surroundings; and grim, as influenza and loss of life beset his troopship. In Book V, “Bidding the Eagles of the West Fly On,” Claude stands on the threshold of new vistas: He embraces the nobility of his purpose as a soldier; France, its people and culture; and camaraderie with an internationally acclaimed violinist-turned-soldier. Claude’s love of music is finally free to find expression as well.
Ultimately, the hero of One of Ours, Claude Wheeler, gave his life in service to his country, as did Cather’s cousin Grosvenor. Of the fictional soldier, Cather wrote, “He died believing his own country better than it is, and France better than any country can ever be. And those were beautiful beliefs to die with.” To her aunt Frances, mother of Grosvenor, Cather consoled in a letter, he “died a glorious death in a great cause.” Grosvenor was posthumously awarded the Distinguished Service Cross. Despite the Cather family’s desire for France as his final resting place, Grosvenor’s widow arranged to have his body returned to the states for burial at East Lawn Cemetery in Bladen, Nebraska.
Click the link below to listen to the playlist for One of Ours:
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6LaslyUvyneHPH6nqu4GVP
Companion Playlist Highlights Musical Event in Cather's Life
Internationally renowned violinist David Hochstein (1892-1918) was the prototype for the fictional David Gerhardt, friend of Claude Wheeler, in Cather’s One of Ours. “I wanted my red-headed soldier from a prairie farm to 'get some of his back,' . . . through a fine friendship,” Cather said in a New York Herald interview published December 24, 1922. During the course of the interview, Cather spoke of having met Hochstein on three occasions, the first taking place in 1916 when a group of musician friends gathered at an apartment in New York's Wellington Hotel. “They played a lot of chamber music that afternoon, Schubert's Death and the Maiden among other things, but what I particularly remember was their beautiful playing of Schubert's Die Forelle (The Trout) . . .” said Cather. Our second playlist is built around Cather's memorable afternoon of music with Hochstein and friends. Tragically, the violinist was killed in the Battle of Argonne while serving with the United States Army.
Click the link below to listen to music played during a memorable afternoon Cather spent with acclaimed violinist David Hochstein:
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4MdukAWdEroYwXjHHnL6Ft